Thomas W. Piper was indicted for the murder of Mabel H. Young in June 1875, tried for the offence in December 1875, but when this trial resulted in the disagreement of the jury, was again tried on 31st January 1876. Five-year-old Mabel had attended the church Sabbath-school with her aunt on May 23rd, 1874, but after the class she disappeared. The little girl was later found, badly beaten and the church sexton, Piper, was arrested and charged with the crime. She died from her injuries a day later.